Saw this explanation of "writing funny" from The Dilbert Blog.
Made me wonder - how well do spirituality and being funny go together? If "being funny" is a skill - and thus has it's own line of development - can you be 2nd tier funny? Enlightened funny?
Dilbert points out six essential elements of humor:
Clever
Cute
Bizarre
Cruel
Naughty
Recognizable
The cute, cruel and bizarre elements - a bunny with a bazooka, is the example. Not really apropos for spiritual discussion. (Prove me wrong here - someone write a deeply wise spiritual story about a bunny and a bazooka! Please?)
Most of the spiritual teachers I have met actually are good-hearted people who love laughing. But they weren't really that funny - cute and clever, at the best.
But the rip-roaring comedy seems to stem from two parts smart-@ss, mixed with the elements above.
And smart-@ssery isn't usually a very spiritual thing - usually it's the 'lesser developed' narcissistic aspects of one's personality that is the smart'@ass.
Stuart Davis seems to be the best representative of 2nd tier smart-@ssery we have so far -and he does it great, in my opinion. Of course, at the same time, he's a total narcissist exhibitionist. BUT - tt does seem most of the time though, he manages to be a total narcissistic exhibitionist, while being a fully relational human being and not a complete introvert, despite his claims. (you have to scroll down in this entry, past a lot to get to his frank admittance, but it's worth it, because it's a great blogpost.)
To be fully human, and fully enlightened, I do think "true" humor (not the fake stuff/fake laughs we do to paper over wounds) is one of the most valuable gifts we get from others, and one of the most integral/whole.
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
This Month
Recent Articles
Integral Views
Month Archive
Recent Photos
|
Humor and Spirituality - Do They Go Together?
Comments
Re: Humor and Spirituality - Do They Go Together?
by
Anonymous
on Tue 17 Jul 2007 02:41 PM PDT | Permanent Link
Being the author of "Laughing Your Way to Enlightenment," I feel I have some authoritative points to make on this topic. [I'm glad I didn't say I was the writer of that article, because then my points would be writeritative.
I think that all humor -- 3 Stooges, Adam Sandler, Woody Allen's, HHDL's -- retains it's zing, once we are enlightened. If there is surprize, we non-judgmentally have to laugh. But, yeah, on the road to The Big Kahuna, we can become over-serious. Nothing bad about that; some people need to mature, turn from being green to yellow bananas. But, of course, I'm only speculating here. Re: Re: Humor and Spirituality - Do They Go Together?
by
Anonymous
on Tue 17 Jul 2007 02:47 PM PDT | Permanent Link
Before enlightenment, a whoopee cushion is funny; when you realize enlightenment a whoopee cushion isn't funny; after enlightenment a whoopee cushion is funny again.
-- JEFF WILSON Re: Re: Humor and Spirituality - Do They Go Together?
by
Anonymous
on Tue 17 Jul 2007 03:03 PM PDT | Permanent Link
Let me change that next-to-the-last sentence to make it funnier with an Integral context:
Nothing bad about that; some people need to mature, turn from slipping on green banana peels to slipping on yellow ones, giving them hope of one day slipping on indigo ones. -- Tom Armstrong Re: Re: Re: Humor and Spirituality - Do They Go Together?
by
ebuddha
on Wed 18 Jul 2007 09:54 PM PDT | Profile | Permanent Link
Well, easy for you to say - you're one of the funnier "integral/spiritual" bloggers. (still smile about steve's mom holding up a sign looking at I-I).
But my example above is an interesting one - all of that concern, conflict and humor, arose out of CONTROVERSY. Not necessarily indigo! Re: Re: Humor and Spirituality - Do They Go Together?
by
ebuddha
on Wed 18 Jul 2007 09:51 PM PDT | Profile | Permanent Link
I hadn't heard of that book, before, but it makes sense!
Re: Humor and Spirituality - Do They Go Together?
by
coolmel
on Wed 18 Jul 2007 04:48 AM PDT | Profile | Permanent Link
i have a problem with the notion of "2nd tier funny".
for instance, if you're just 2nd tier funny then only less than 2% of the population will laugh at your joke. good luck in finding those 2%. to me, funny is funny. integral or otherwise. i just draw the line when humor is used to denigrate people, too much. we all have our limits. for the record, Ken Wilber is one of the funniest philosophers out there. but Scott Adams is hand down the funniest blogger. ~C Re: Re: Humor and Spirituality - Do They Go Together?
by
Apollo
on Wed 18 Jul 2007 09:35 PM PDT | Permanent Link
I imagine "2nd tier funny" being humour capacity that can touch people at various waves of development. You could have the capacity for a range from slapstick to high level plays on words and know when and how to use each piece of comedy.
Re: Re: Humor and Spirituality - Do They Go Together?
by
ebuddha
on Wed 18 Jul 2007 09:57 PM PDT | Profile | Permanent Link
Ken can be pretty funny. I also think Fake Steve Jobs does a good job with the humor.
Hey - I got you to use coolmel! Sweet!! :) Re: Re: Humor and Spirituality - Do They Go Together?
by
Amanda
on Thu 21 Feb 2008 04:27 PM PST | Permanent Link
I've been thinking abouthumor for years. The best definition I've come up with so far is that funny comes from a sudden shift of perspective: Time flies like an arrow, fruit flies like a banana.
Maybe in the state of Big Mind there is no perspective to shift, but I'm guessing in most stages we still have a human perspective that can be thrown for a loop. -Amanda Re: Humor and Spirituality - Do They Go Together?
by
Anonymous
on Thu 11 Jun 2009 09:18 AM PDT | Permanent Link
Alternative Theories of Spirituality by Karen Lee
add your own 1. The Auntie Mame theory: life is a banquet 2. The LaVerne and Shirley theory: we're all doing it our way. 3. The Prego spaghetti sauce theory: Life is abundant; it's all in there 4. The Tootsie Roll Pop theory: We all have a perfect inner essence; conditioning gives us a hard outer shell to break through. 5. The Reverse Paranoid theory: Life is out to do us good. 6. The Caterpiller theory: If we just move our two front legs, the rest will follow. 7. The WD-40 theory: Willingness is the WD-40 of the universe. 8. The Mary Tyler Moore Show theory: love is all around you. 9. The Happy Days theory: they're all happy whether we know it or not. 10. The All in the Family theory: We are all one, may all being awaken to itself. 11. The Campbells Quantum Soup theory: possibilities are endless and so is the deepening. Namaste Om shanti, shanti om Trackbacks
TrackBack URL: |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||